Tuesday, February 02, 2010

Many Thanks, Mr. Salinger

I wasn't exactly sad to hear of JD Salinger's death because if you've had the desire to hang on until the age of 91, you've probably lived a pretty good and fulfilling life.  But I felt an immediate sense of apprehension because I love Salinger and I've always felt  protective of him.  His reclusiveness never bothered me, having the occasional desire myself, and I always felt resentful on his behalf whenever anyone talked of it disparagingly.

Catcher in the Rye is one of my favorite books.  I read it when I was one year older than Holden and out on my own for the first time.  But I can't say I related to Holden exactly.  I didn't have anywhere near enough sense of self to judge anyone else a "phony."  But it also never occurred to me that exposing the phonies was the point of the book.

It seems that it's popular to dismiss Holden Caulfield as a spoiled upper class brat or an unrealistic purist.  Even the compliments reduce him to a rebel without a cause in the silly, over-glorification of teen angst, à la The Breakfast Club.

I never saw him as any of that and patiently waited to find out the cause of his disenchantment, which it seems was death of his little brother.  Of all the things that were causing him to despair, that one was the one thing he couldn't just leave.  Moving to that cabin in the woods would take him away from all the phonies, but it wouldn't take him away from that great pain.

An event like that would cause anyone angst, not just a sensitive teenager, so by the end of the book, it seemed that Holden was simply trying to find beauty and truth in a world that was so relentlessly unsparing as to no longer contain someone who had been so dearly loved, and the agonizing search was paid for with his sanity and to an extent, his freedom.  Whether he found enough beauty to redeem the world is irrelevant; it would seem that he hadn't by the book's end.  I think he showed it to us, but hadn't found it himself.  Truthfully, I don't think it was that important.  I think it was more important just to hear what he had to say while he was looking.  There's no reason to demand the character reach the same conclusions we have.

I also think it was important for Holden to be a teenager in the story because it's unforgivable for a rational adult to go 'round the twist like that.  A teenager is old enough to not need his hand held as he roams the city, and we are able to examine the intricacies of grief and despair and the psychological trauma surrounding them without having them filtered through the complications of adult responsibilities which easily stunt such an examination.  If Holden was an adult, inevitably we would have to see how his grief affected those with whom he was forced to interact, and we'd judge him harshly for not controlling himself for the sake of others.  But with Holden being a teenager, we can see that grief and the accompanying vulnerability as the intensely personal thing that it is.

But Catcher, even though it's one of my favorite books, isn't even my favorite Salinger book.  That would be Franny and Zooey.  This was the book I related to. Franny and Zooey are the youngest of 7 gifted and talented siblings.  One of the main themes of the book is confronting ego.  Too deep an analysis will not make a good blog post, but the request to "do it for the Fat Lady" made me want to cry. My love for this book is only heightened by the fact that I consider Franny to be a female literary creation on par with Brett Ashley from Hemingway's The Sun Also Rises.  I know I'm being enigmatic, but I don't want to rehash the plot, and would really just enjoy discussing it with someone who has read it.

I'm probably going overboard in the way breathless fans do, but it bothers me not.  I guess I'm too old to pretend to be unaffected by that which I genuinely love.

I'd welcome a literary discussion if anyone is up to it.  If not, I'm sure I'll have sex soon or find myself in an awkward situation.  I'm very much aware that literary criticism is not my true talent...

9 comments:

trashman said...

HUH? Maybe there was no hidden meaning. Maybe it was just a book. Mybe I'm not smart enough to what the fuck you're talking about. Or maybe I'm too smart to care. Maybe we'll never know. Maybe we will. Maybe I'll stop now. Maybe I wont. I guess I wont. Or did I?

trashman said...

BTW. I thought Catcher in the Rye was about that dude that built a ball park in a field.

Zelda said...

Not too much hidden in Catcher in the Rye, but it's difficult to hide a ballpark...

Jen said...

I remember when you gave me Franny and Zooey to read when we were in college - I loved it. A few years ago, I read Raise High the Roof Beams, Carpenter and Seymour and it made me go back and re-read Franny and Zooey again. I laughed all over again.

It was sad to hear about his death, but he did lead a very long life and he hadn't published anything new since 1965. I think it would be a bit more upsetting if he was still actively writing, then it would feel like maybe his work wasn't done before he died.

ghostie alix said...

zelda, that was an artful and human tribute. makes me want to revisit.

Zelda said...

Yeah, his death wasn't exactly sad news. The only thing that irritates me is reviews of Catcher and Franny and Zooey that seem to miss important aspects in their haste to cast them into a genre.

Zelda said...

Thanks, ghostie. I recommend it.

Anonymous said...

Reading these kind of posts reminds me of just how technology truly is ubiquitous in this day and age, and I think it is safe to say that we have passed the point of no return in our relationship with technology.


I don't mean this in a bad way, of course! Ethical concerns aside... I just hope that as the price of memory drops, the possibility of uploading our brains onto a digital medium becomes a true reality. It's a fantasy that I daydream about every once in a while.


(Posted on Nintendo DS running [url=http://quizilla.teennick.com/stories/16129580/does-the-r4-or-r4i-work-with-the-new-ds]r4i dsi[/url] DS NetSurf)

Anonymous said...

Bring approximate the monster with two backs casinos? countenance this advanced [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com]casino[/url] helmsman and tie on up online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at www.realcazinoz.com .
you can also into our opposite [url=http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com]casino[/url] mastery at http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com and dethrone be realized to everything apportionment !
another all the hysterics [url=http://www.ttittancasino.com]casino spiele[/url] ploy is www.ttittancasino.com , pro german gamblers, slip in unrestrained online casino bonus.